Growing Pains
Take 40 children, ages 8-15, and dump them in a ghost town in the desert of New Mexico for 40 days, and see how they fare. Sounds a little harsh, but hey, they did sign up for it. Okay, I can understand some of the criticism for the first few shows. The initial task the kids, who had never met before, were given was to haul several large carts, carrying a 40-day supply of dried and canned goods, a mile or three through the desert to the town. Then they are more or less on their own to figure it out.
Critics jumped all over this, hauling the carts in particular, as cruel, abusive, and possibly violating child labor laws. Have none of these people ever heard of a team-building exercise? I think it was brilliant. No adults, make all the decisions yourselves. One boy pulled a muscle in his leg. The oldest boy lifted him onto the top of the heaping cart and pulled him the rest of the way into town. Another boy, one of the district leaders, thought he was doing enough work by walking at the front of the pack and yelling, "Pull!" That same older boy that helped the injured kid told the bossy kid to do some real work, try pulling the cart for a minute. He couldn't budge it. The older boy, his point made, let the kid off the hook and continued to pull the cart.
An opportunity for children to take the lessons they have learned of what NOT to do from adults and apply them to real life, and also at the same time maybe coming to understand that the decisions that adults make may not always be popular, but there is usually a good reason behind them.
Each episode covers 3 to 4 days, and one day an adult appears to host a, "showdown." The kids have split themselves into four districts, and each district competes for their placement in the social hierarchy. The first-placed district becomes the "upper class". They have zero assigned responsibilities and make the most money - $1.00 a day. Second place becomes the "merchants". They make 50 cents a day operating the General Store where the kids can spend their hard-earned cash on the luxuries in life, such as candy or toys. Third place is the "cooks", who, you guessed it, get 25 cents a day to cook and wash up for the whole crew. And last place are the lowly laborers, who get 10 cents a day to do the heavy lifting, like carrying water from the well and cleaning the outhouses.
Each district was initially assigned a District Leader, some of whom do a good job, one of whom I would like to strangle with my bare hands. You need only to watch 10 minutes of one episode to figure out which one I am referring to.
Each showdown is allotted a certain amount of time for all four districts to complete a task. If all four districts finish in time, they win a giant reward for the whole town. But it is always a choice between two prizes, one is usually an instant gratification luxury, the other less-sexy-but-more-necessary. These are kids. The choice usually seems obvious, but the end result may surprise you.
I think the first few episodes turned some people off because they were sometimes difficult to watch. A lot of the kids were extremely homesick and a little scared. And it is a high-pressure situation throughout. There are tears on every episode so far. But only five episodes into it, a little over two weeks in real time with more than three weeks to go, and you can see the vast difference in the way these children work together, the way they see each other and the way they see themselves.
As I watch each episode, I think of the parents of these children watching and what they must think of their own kids. Many of them will be very proud. Some of them should be very embarassed, but, seeing first-hand the values that these same parents have instilled in their bratty children, it will probably take them several episodes to do so, if they see it at all.
I don't think the show is cruel at all. I think what makes it difficult to watch at times is that this is what children are really like when there are not adults around. Sometimes they are viscious to each other. Sometimes they are sad and lonely. Often they are disrespectful and obnoxious. But put in a situation where they determine their own hierarchy, things usually sort themselves out just fine. The quiet ones learn how to stand up for themselves, the bratty ones learn that popularity can be short-lived, and the intelligent and compassionate ones help to guide the shift in the balance of power by leading by example.
The program makes me think about my own childhood, things I had and things I did not. My parents made ends meet, but we didn't have money, or even time, for lessons for music or karate or everything else under the sun. Most of the kids in my suburban neighborhood grew up the same way. There were 70 (no exaggeration) school-age children in a one-block radius of my house, and our afternoons and evenings were spent together, figuring things out for ourselves in very much the same way that the kids on this show do. Smetimes there was a rising star among us who would let the power go to his or her head, and eventually the natives would revolt, join forces, and put that person back into their place, and back into perspective. None of us did drugs or drank. None of us were giving or receiving oral sex and justifying it as not really being sex. Many of us were "latch-key kids". We used our imaginations, we had a lot of fun, we made real friends and we made real decisions. We were allowed to be children. I fear that that is becoming a lost art.

